Caliber Acquires Tonto Oaks Apartments For $9 Million

A Caliber-sponsored investment fund has acquired Tonto Oaks Apartments in Payson, Arizona, for $9 million. The purchase price for the 45-unit community equals approximately $200,000 per apartment. Caliber completed the acquisition using bridge financing and increased its fair-value assets under management by approximately $9 million.

Second Payson Multifamily Community

Tonto Oaks was built in 1995 and offers one- and two-bedroom apartments. The property was approximately 98% occupied at the time of the acquisition.

Caliber now manages 87 units across Tonto Oaks and West Frontier Apartments, making it one of Payson’s larger apartment owners by its estimate.

The company plans to complete lighter renovations without taking the entire property offline. This approach is intended to improve individual units while preserving rental income.

Caliber also expects to improve property management and eventually replace its bridge financing with longer-term debt.

Payson sits around 80 to 90 minutes northeast of Phoenix and has attracted residents seeking a mountain climate. Local demand is supported by healthcare, tourism and recreation, while Caliber said no new apartment supply is currently under construction.

KEY QUOTES:

We sold most of our multifamily portfolio before interest rates rose and committed to buying back in when values reset. Today we are seeing opportunities to buy apartments at more attractive prices than we have seen in years, and Tonto Oaks is our second value-add multifamily acquisition of this cycle. Tonto Oaks is an occupied, cash-flowing property where a light renovation can raise the quality of the units without taking the building offline, so it keeps producing income while the work gets done. It is the same playbook we are running at West Frontier: renovate the units, improve the management, and serve a market with steady demand and no new apartment supply under construction.

Chris Loeffler, Co-Founder and CEO of Caliber